Three banks, three file formats: Mark Maxham on what a shared data standard catches
Mark Maxham thinks the opportunities for simple standardization outside mobility are, in his word, rampant. He gave me two from his own week.
The first was a friend complaining about bank records. The friend uses three banks, wanted to download the records from all three, and got three different file formats. Why, they asked, can't I just get a CSV file that I can use for everything? There is no technical reason. Nobody ever agreed on one, so every bank exports its own way, and every person who wants to put their own money in one place does the reconciliation by hand.
The second was more serious. A friend of his at the National Transportation Safety Board describes a pattern investigators see: a run of car crashes with no obvious connection, until someone notices that the cars share a supplier's component. Mark named a supplier and then apologized for it, because the point is not one company.
If there were, for example, a way for the car companies to publish in a consistent fashion the bill of materials for every single vehicle, then the moment you've got 10 or 20 car crashes, you can start to investigate what's the common element. Because right now, you might have to end up with five or 600 dead people before it even merits getting looked at.
That number is his estimate, not a statistic, but the pattern behind it is familiar. General Motors recalled millions of cars in 2014 for an ignition switch that had been causing crashes for years, and the compensation fund it set up later counted 124 deaths. A consistent, published bill of materials would not prevent a bad part. It would make the pattern visible sooner, to investigators and to software that looks for patterns across every crash report.
He was clear that a standard like that costs the manufacturers nothing that matters. A common format for publishing what is in a car does not wreck anyone's business model. A carmaker's intellectual property is the design, the support, the advertising and the brand. The list of parts, in a format a computer can read, is not where they compete.
That is the thread through everything Mark told me that day. The scooter rules worked because cities and companies agreed what a vehicle's status means. Bank statements and parts lists are the same problem in other industries. The standard itself is boring, and the value is in what you can compute once everyone uses it. Regulation turns into a query, and a safety investigation turns into a search.
He ended by saying he could go on and on about the adjacent opportunities, standards that would make businesses run smoother, make dealing with government dramatically less painful and increase competition. Most industries have their own version of three banks with three formats. The useful question is what you could find out if they all used one.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 13 November 2020.
