← Back to Posts

Spectrum by the factory: Mark Collier on private 5G

Sean Roberts•December 18, 2020•4 min read

Mark Collier and I spent the second half of our conversation on what small companies are building now that spectrum is no longer reserved for carriers. I started with someone we both know. Boris Renski, a colleague Mark and I both know well from OpenStack, has started FreedomFi, which builds enterprise 5G on open source, and other companies are doing similar work. They are not waiting for the FCC or anyone else to catch up.

Mark's example of why it matters was a factory.

If you want to track everything that's going on, all the robotics, all the things that are happening on the line, it's all sensors, right? So more sensors means more data, but you want to connect it all and have a real-time look at it. If you do that with Wi-Fi, there's just a lot of issues with that. A microwave oven can disrupt the signal. It's just not really industrial grade.

Wi-Fi is great, he said, and it is about as permissionless as wireless gets: shared spectrum with some rules, but pretty much the Wild West. A private 5G or LTE network uses the same technology as a mobile carrier but belongs to one company in one building. That brings the reliability and performance a production line needs, and latency profiles Wi-Fi cannot offer. All the innovation that came out of Wi-Fi over the years, he thinks, can go to another level here.

What makes it possible is the way CBRS hands out spectrum. A company can reserve spectrum for its own location, not for a whole state like Texas or California, and not for the whole country. It may be getting it for a very small space. That is more efficient precisely because nobody knows exactly how people will want to use it. If you try to predetermine every use case, he said, you will miss most of them, because the world is full of smart people with different ideas. Open source works the same way, and hyper-local spectrum licensing that is dynamic and can be reallocated gives those people room.

His second point was a project. Magma is an open source mobile packet core, the part of a mobile network that routes subscribers' traffic. It came out of Facebook, whose network engineers are among the best in the world, and the Open Infrastructure Foundation, as Mark's foundation is about to be renamed, is helping to promote it. Because it is open source, people like Boris can contribute to it, turn it into products and bring private LTE and private 5G to market. Mark expects we will be hearing a lot more about it.

The shared licenses make this a builder's opportunity rather than a carrier's. Until now, a factory that wanted engineered wireless rather than best-effort Wi-Fi had to buy it from a mobile operator. With a county-sized license, a database that tells every base station when it may transmit, and an open source core, a small team can build that network for one site. The FCC auctioned the first of those licenses this summer.

I ended with a prediction of my own, and said so: I have no inside information. Since we moved off mainframes and serial lines, physical, wired networks have dominated for thirty or forty years. It feels to me that we are on the cusp of mobile communication becoming the default and wired becoming the exception. Mark agreed. The first half of our conversation, on how software is setting the standards, is here: software is setting the standards.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 18 December 2020.

Share this post