← Back to Posts

Every complex question has a simple answer, and it's wrong: Mark Maxham on regulating social media

Sean Roberts•January 8, 2021•3 min read

When people ask what should be done about social media, Mark Maxham's first move is to ask what, specifically, the problem is. If the worry is propaganda, then yes, someone has to work out how to handle falsehood. But how? What is truth, he asked. There are things he considers objectively true that cousins and friends of his believe are objectively false. Deepfakes are getting better, and even presenting true facts selectively can turn a reader around. These are hard problems, and he did not pretend to have the answer. He was sure about one thing, though. Breaking up the company is such a low-creativity approach.

He was also impatient with a common confusion. The First Amendment restrains the government, not companies. Facebook, Twitter and Reddit are companies, and as long as they stay within the law around them, they decide what appears on their own services. Anyone who calls a platform's moderation decision a First Amendment violation, he said, should go and read some civics. And people who do not like one platform's rules have others, from the partisan to the determinedly neutral, like Wikipedia.

So what is the middle ground between heavy-handed and useless? He does not know, but he has a candidate, and he works in it.

I feel like the OMF is like this petri dish for, maybe this is a solution. Maybe this is the genesis of a bunch of different solutions. There are a lot of hard problems out there. And one of my favorite aphorisms is, every complex question has a simple answer, and it's wrong. To say government is not the answer, that's wrong. Government is the answer, that's also wrong. What's right? That's where it doesn't break down to one sentence.

The aphorism descends from H. L. Mencken, who wrote in 1920 that every human problem has a well-known solution that is neat, plausible and wrong. Mark's use of it is precise. What does work, in his experience at the Open Mobility Foundation, is bringing organizations that are in conflict to one table, finding the common ground, and building a shared language, whether that is an API or simply a set of shared terms and values. Cities and scooter companies did not trust each other. They agreed on how to describe a vehicle, a trip and a rule, and a great deal of argument disappeared. He wondered whether the same pattern could work for big tech and little tech, trade, commerce, even immigration.

The hard part, he said, is addressing complexity in a way that does not undermine people's faith that humans can solve hard problems. Every confident simple answer that fails makes the next attempt harder to believe.

That is a demanding standard for anyone working on platform policy, and I think it is the right one. Most of the proposals in circulation fit in one sentence: break them up, repeal the liability shield, leave them alone, make them neutral. Each is easy to repeat, and each, by Mark's rule, is wrong. What might work, a standing table where the platforms, the people they affect and the public agree on the terms they share and then build to them, cannot be said in a slogan. That may be the best evidence that it is worth trying.

The first half of this conversation was about why the problem moves so fast: a thousand people can build what took a million.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 8 January 2021.

Share this post