← Back to Posts

322 vehicles over the cap: Mark Maxham on rules that run as code

Sean Roberts•November 13, 2020•3 min read

Most of the people arguing about big tech this year have never shipped software. Mark Maxham has, which is why I wanted him for this. He is Director of Platform Software at Lacuna and also works through its subsidiary, Ellis & Associates, which is under contract to advise the City of Los Angeles and other cities on mobility. Two hats, as he says, and as far as he can tell they do not conflict.

The story starts with scooters, which is less trivial than it sounds. Los Angeles had already been overrun once, by Uber and Lyft, and had spent years in arrears. When the scooter companies showed up the city decided to get out in front for once. Scooters were a good place to start: one vehicle, one rider, small, expensive, and run by startups hungry enough to negotiate. Instead of a permit and a prayer, LA asked for data in a common format, and that format became the Mobility Data Specification, now maintained by the Open Mobility Foundation and used, Mark says, in more than a hundred cities.

The specification itself is almost boring, which is the point. For every vehicle in the public right of way: latitude and longitude, make and model, and its disposition. Is it in a ride? Available for rent on the sidewalk? Unavailable because the battery is low or it is down for maintenance? Back at the warehouse? Out of the city? Stolen? That shared vocabulary between a city and the operators turns out to do two different jobs. Looking backward it answers the planning questions: where did they go, what did they do, were the companies inside their caps. Looking forward it tells the city where every scooter is right now, so that for a fire, a stadium event or a street fair it can open an area up or clear it out, in something close to real time. Regulation by a police officer with a pad of paper, Mark said, would be intractable at that scale.

Then he said the thing I had asked him on to say.

It's a win for the city, but it's also a win to have uniform digital regulations for the scooter companies that are in human readable format, but they're fundamentally digital, which means that the execution of code can measure: okay, all the scooters are in these positions, and here are the rules. I can basically just take that information plus the rules and run it through some code and pop out the answer. Are the companies in compliance or are they not? And if they aren't, then we can be incredibly precise and say, oh, you're 322 vehicles over the cap. And these particular vehicles are not where they're supposed to be.

No month-end report, no argument about what the permit meant. A rule, the data, and a number.

The part that I think gets missed in the big tech debate is why a standard beats a city writing its own rules. Mark laid out the alternatives. The companies run amok and the city plays catch-up. Or the city dispatches rules unilaterally that turn out to be unenforceable, onerous or privacy-invasive. Or, the version that quietly favors the incumbents, every city asks for its own bespoke data in its own format, and only a company backed by an Uber or a Lyft can throw a hundred engineers at compliance. He compared it to the complaint about GDPR in Europe, that only Google and Facebook can afford to comply. A startup with six engineers cannot. The foundation exists to put the cities, the operators and the software vendors at one table and hash out the interface once.

Mark said something near the end that I have believed for a long time and rarely hear said plainly. Interfaces are the interesting part. The web, email, streaming video, all of it runs on agreed interfaces that let parties with different interests work together without asking permission each time. An API is not a buzzword here. It is two organizations agreeing on how they will talk, which is a bigger deal than the SDK revolution of the 1990s that only defined the tools.

Governance through an API, between a city, a company and the open source software they both maintain. Still early, as he kept saying. Also already running in a hundred cities.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 13 November 2020.

Share this post