← Back to Posts

You cannot copyright the order: Daniel Takash on APIs and Google v. Oracle

Sean Roberts•December 10, 2020•4 min read

Oracle sued Google in 2010 over Android's use of the Java APIs. A jury found Google's use fair in 2016, the Federal Circuit threw that out in 2018, and the Supreme Court heard the case by telephone on 7 October. I asked Daniel Takash of the Niskanen Center what happens next. He did not predict a winner. He mapped the roads.

The first road is procedural. In May the Court surprised a lot of people by asking both sides for extra briefing on the standard of review: should the Federal Circuit have deferred to the jury's finding of fair use instead of deciding the question fresh? Daniel thinks the justices take that road if they are not comfortable deciding whether an API is different from the rest of a program's code. They send it back, let the lower courts draw a sharper line between code in general and code that lets programs talk to each other, and the case returns to them in a few years.

The second road is the one he wants: a ruling that the interfaces Google reimplemented cannot be copyrighted at all. This is where the salad came in.

If you are at a restaurant and you ask the waiter for a Caesar salad or something like that, you do not need to tell the waiter, put these ingredients in and do this to it. The recipe and the actual process of putting it together, that is the implementing code that goes on behind the scenes. You asking the waiter, I would like a Caesar salad, that is the API.

Google wrote its own kitchen. What it copied was the menu, the declarations that tell a Java programmer what to ask for. Daniel's argument is that something so abstract, with so few ways to express it in Java, is not the kind of thing copyright protects. A ruling on those grounds would be a significant win for what some people call adversarial interoperability. If Facebook held a copyright on its interfaces, anyone building a different front end to show you your own photos and posts would have to license them from Facebook or start from scratch.

He gave Oracle's lawyers their due. A barrier to reimplementation, they argued, does not by itself make something ineligible for copyright. That is true, he said, but it depends on how high the barrier is, and if we care about competition, policy should keep it as low as possible.

The third road is fair use: the interfaces are copyrightable, but Google's use was fair. Daniel leans that way on the merits. What Google used was small next to the whole Java platform, and the material is so functional that even a commercial use weighs toward fair use. He would not look further into the crystal ball than that.

What struck me most was his view of what follows a loss. The House antitrust report in October called for interoperability and data portability. If the Court holds that APIs are copyrightable and Google's use was not fair, he expects Congress to act, either by taking interfaces out of copyright or by giving software a legal category of its own. Senator Thom Tillis has spent this year holding hearings on rewriting the DMCA, so a vehicle may already be moving. Daniel also reached back to the phone network. Policy made the phone companies connect to one another, so nobody needs a separate phone to call friends on another carrier. Twenty or thirty years from now, he thinks, needing Facebook's own front end to see what is posted on Facebook may look just as strange.

Much of the software industry depends on reimplementing someone else's interfaces. Linux reimplemented the Unix system calls. A whole category of storage products speaks Amazon's S3 API. The question is not new either: the Court split four to four over Lotus's menus in 1996 and left it unanswered. When this decision comes, read it for which of Daniel's three roads the Court took, not only for who won, because the road decides what the next developer is allowed to build.

As he put it at the end, 2020 has been one hell of a year, and it is hard to make predictions, especially about the future.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 10 December 2020.

Share this post