← Back to Posts

Terms of service with a federal backstop: Daniel Takash on blocking a rival

Sean Roberts•December 10, 2020•4 min read

Partway through our conversation about the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, Daniel Takash mentioned the eighteen-thousand-page document that arrives every time you update iTunes. I said it arrives every day. He agreed that nobody could read through the terms of service, and then made the point that turned the conversation from criminal justice to competition. Terms of service are private law. One party writes them, people who never read them accept them, and the company changes them whenever it likes.

That would only be an annoyance if the terms were just a contract. They may be more than that. The CFAA punishes anyone who exceeds authorized access to a computer, and if breaking a website's terms counts as exceeding your authorization, then a contract almost nobody reads is backed by federal criminal law. Aaron Swartz was prosecuted for downloading articles from JSTOR in violation of its terms. Daniel's bigger worry is not users like him. It is companies.

It's not just some simple user violating a terms of service, but rather it's a company that perhaps wants to create a different interface, a different front end for Facebook or Gmail or YouTube. If one of these companies puts in their terms of service, you're not allowed to use a different interface, and then a company wants to develop that, they could potentially be liable, or their users could be liable, under the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act. And I think that creates a very harsh barrier backed by the federal criminal justice system.

The courts have not gone quite that far, at least not in the circuit where most of these companies live. The Ninth Circuit has held that breaking a site's terms of use, without more, is not a CFAA violation. But in 2016 the same court decided Facebook's case against Power Ventures, a small company that let people see their accounts on several social networks in one place, with those users' permission. Facebook sent Power a cease-and-desist letter and blocked its IP addresses. Power kept going, and the court held that from the moment the letter arrived, Power's access was unauthorized, whatever its users wanted. The terms alone could not make Power a lawbreaker. The letter could.

In September 2019 the same court let hiQ Labs keep collecting public LinkedIn profiles over LinkedIn's objection, and LinkedIn has asked the Supreme Court to take the case. Whatever the justices say in Van Buren, argued on 30 November, will shape both lines of cases.

A few days ago Charles Duan described front ends you choose yourself, built on a platform's data the way mail clients sit on top of mail servers. Daniel's point is the legal shadow over that idea. A startup can write the client. The platform can write one sentence into its terms, send a letter, and turn the startup's next login into a federal question. Most founders will not wait to learn how that question is answered. They will build something else.

We need to look at the way in which terms of service function as private law, and how just putting certain provisions in the terms of service could strangle any competition before it even has the slightest chance of getting off the ground.

That is the passage I would hand to anyone working on competition policy next year. Breaking up a company is slow, uncertain and fought in court for a decade. Making sure a company cannot use the criminal code to stop a rival from building a better window onto its users' own data is a narrow change, and it could matter as much.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 10 December 2020.

Share this post