← Back to Posts

Interoperability takes nothing away: Charles Duan on competing without rebuilding the network

Sean Roberts•December 5, 2020•3 min read

Near the end of our conversation I asked Charles Duan the political question. Congress and several states are working on the idea that some technology companies have become too dominant. Apple and Epic Games have been fighting over the App Store since August, and plenty of people feel that somebody has to do something. The tool at hand is antitrust, with consent decrees for mergers. If people in technology policy and engineering could agree on concrete alternatives, could we head off break-up legislation, or at least work with it?

That is the hope, he said, and then he made the case for interoperability as the alternative.

Most of the interest in antitrust is in trying to break these companies apart. And the idea behind something like interoperability is that it doesn't actually take away anything from Facebook. It opens the door for competitors to actually be able to compete on a level playing field without having to build up the same sorts of large networks or bases of users that these other companies have already built up.

The second half of his argument is about switching. A person on one big social network could move to another without giving up everything they have put into the first one: the connections, the history, the years of posts. Interoperability opens competition without tearing down what is already there.

He was careful about scope. There is no reason everything has to be opened, he said, and no reason it should be. The hard part is identifying the key assets, the specific things that stop a competitor with a better product from getting started, and opening those. Get that right, and interoperability works very well as a way of increasing competition without having to use antitrust to do it.

The House antitrust subcommittee's report in October recommended both kinds of remedy, structural separations on one side and interoperability and data portability on the other. Charles's point is that the two are not equal in cost. A break-up removes value along with power, because some of what the integrated company offers is genuinely useful. Opening the right interfaces removes the power and keeps the value.

I would add one honest qualification, which I think he would accept. Interoperability takes away nothing Facebook makes, but it does take away lock-in, and lock-in is worth a great deal to a dominant platform. That is the point. A user who can leave without losing their network is a user the platform has to keep earning. Competition comes back through that door, not through a court order dividing the company in two.

As we wrapped up I promised more examples next time, from Apple's devices to Tesla's cars. Charles said what interests him most is that people tend to see interoperability as just another mandate, and it is much more than that. It is a way of designing markets so the next company can plug in. Who should write those interfaces was the middle of our conversation, and why it matters to users was the start.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 5 December 2020.

Share this post