Government power, corporate power: Mark Maxham on what each side fears
How many airlines is the right number of airlines? Mark Maxham asked me that when I pressed him on mergers. People say consolidation is bad, and sometimes it is: nobody wants a few companies to own a market outright. But would a hundred Ubers instead of one benefit anybody? He is not going to install a hundred of those apps on his phone. Economies of scale are real, and the right number of scooter companies in a city is not a question a statute can answer in advance.
What worried him more was what happens when lawmakers try anyway. A legislator sees a problem and fixes it, and the fix is incomplete, inadequate or just wrong. Every wrong fix teaches people that nothing can be done. He thinks a lot of the anti-government feeling in this country, and elsewhere, reflects a lack of expertise in how rules get made, and also a lack of humility about it.
His alternative is the one he works on. The Open Mobility Foundation brings cities, mobility companies and the software companies that serve them to what he called a neutral-ish table, where the rules are worked out and pre-negotiated in advance. No one, on any of the sides, gets to announce unilaterally how it is going to be. You do not want to give a city, a state or the federal government too much power, and you do not want to give the companies too much either.
Then, with the caveat that he was overgeneralizing, he gave me his own political stance in two sentences.
The right is really worried about government power and the left is really worried about corporate power. And I'm worried about power. And I think that in the same way that the government itself has checks and balances, I think everybody needs to be sort of checking and balancing everybody else as much as possible.
Ten days after a national election, that was a useful sentence to hear from an engineer. It is also how the best open source projects already work. No single member company controls the code. The charter says who can vote, who can block a change and how disputes get settled, and the biggest contributor is bound by the same rules as the smallest. The projects that last are the ones where nobody gets to say how it is going to be.
The scooter rules Mark described earlier that afternoon, the ones that can tell an operator it is 322 vehicles over the cap, came out of that kind of table. The specification started in Los Angeles and moved to a foundation where cities and companies maintain it together. Everyone can read it, and code can check it.
The big technology debate is mostly an argument between the two worries he named. One side wants the government to break the companies up, and the other wants the government to leave them alone. Mark's answer is to worry about power wherever it sits and to build institutions where it checks itself. What that might look like for the largest platforms is where we went next: compete on features, not on closed standards.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 13 November 2020.
