← Back to Posts

Who gets to watch an election: Aaron Ockerman on transparency and privacy

Sean Roberts•October 21, 2020•3 min read

Who is allowed to watch an election? It was a common question this fall, and I asked it of Aaron Ockerman, executive director of the Ohio Association of Election Officials. The voter's worry is simple: can someone walk in off the street and demand to see my ballot, or watch me vote?

The good news, he said, is that this is not new to election officials. Many states have long had statutes governing poll watchers, or observers as Ohio calls them. Those laws respect each person's right to cast a private ballot and balance it against the public's interest in seeing how the work gets done.

I came at it from the transparency side. Across government we expect openness. Public records requests are routine at every level, and apart from personnel files and national security, we expect to see what the government does and to see it easily. Elections are different, because the secret ballot exists for good historical reasons: there is plenty of evidence from a century ago of organized efforts to buy and pressure votes. What the public is owed is transparency about the process, how ballots are gathered, counted, sorted and stored, not about anyone's vote.

Transparency and privacy are somewhat mutually exclusive terms. And so it's always a balancing act in the elections world to provide that transparency to the public, but assure the voters that their ballot is going to be cast privately, and that they're going to be able to cast it free from undue influence or intimidation.

In Ohio the balance is struck by controlling who observes. Observers are appointed by a political party or by an issue campaign, a committee backing a local school levy for example, and registered with the board of elections. Nobody can simply show up and demand a place. They take an oath and go through training. And they observe, which is all the title allows. They cannot talk to voters, tell anyone how to vote, or tell a voter how to feed a ballot into the scanner. If they see a problem, they raise it with the poll workers or call whoever appointed them, and that organization takes it to the board of elections. In his words, transparency is the goal, not interference.

There are more chances to watch than most people realize. Observers can watch the voting machines being tested before election day, watch voting at the polling places, and watch the canvass afterward, when the votes are brought in and counted. Registration lasts for one election, because the rules change from election to election, sometimes dramatically, and an observer who does not know the current rules cannot tell when something is wrong. If you want to observe, the place to start is your local party, which recruits and trains observers. In Ohio, the Secretary of State's office is not part of that process.

What I took away is a design I know from software. Observers are a read-only role. The role is granted by a known party and authenticated with a credential. It is scoped to a time and a place, comes with training, and has a defined escalation path when something looks wrong. That is how you keep a system open to inspection without letting the inspectors change it. Good access control is what makes transparency safe, and it is also what makes intimidation easy to recognize and stop.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 21 October 2020.

Share this post