The cone is competing with Waze: Mark Maxham on road closures as data
Near the end of my conversation with Mark Maxham we got onto the smallest thing we discussed, and it is the one I have repeated to the most people since.
A city crew closes a street. They put cones at both ends. Waze, which cannot see cones, notices that the street has no traffic on it and starts routing people through. The first driver or two go around the cones, because a beeping phone is more persuasive than a piece of orange plastic. Waze sees cars moving on the street, concludes it has found a shortcut, and sends more. Mark has heard this from Los Angeles city officials directly, and they are, in his word, frustrated.
The cone on the street is competing with the Waze app for which one of these is going to tell me what to do. And often the app wins, because it's shiny and it beeps at you and it talks to you, and the cone doesn't. It's just the thing that goes underneath your tire, thump. So the car comes behind a broken water main and the person's like, what happened? Where are my front wheels?
Why does this happen in a city that can tell a scooter company, to the vehicle, that it is 322 over its cap? Because cities do not have a good way to publish a road closure in a digital form. The scooter rules are data, downloaded by the operators and checked by code. The closure is a work order, a paper permit and two cones. There is no feed for the apps to read, so the apps read the traffic instead, and the traffic lies.
It is the same gap Mark had just described for mobility policy, seen from the other side. Once a city publishes exclusion zones as data for scooters, for a fire or a festival or road work, the obvious next step is to publish the road work itself in the same channel, for everyone who drives. He was careful to say there may be things in the works, and some cities may already have something. The point stands. The expensive part of the problem has been solved for one class of vehicle. The dangerous part, the one with a water main at the bottom of it, is still a cone.
For anyone who runs a public works department, that is the question to ask of your systems this year. When a crew closes a road, what tells the phones?
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 13 November 2020.
