Pens and paper: Matt Dunlap on the system that works when the network does not
A statewide voter registration system is a single point of failure. This month Florida's online registration site went down on its deadline day under heavy traffic, and Virginia's went down on its final day when a fiber-optic cable was accidentally cut. Both deadlines were extended. So I asked Matt Dunlap, Maine's Secretary of State, what a voter should do if the registration system fails. His answer was that in Maine it would not matter much.
Maine has no online voter registration. He would like it, especially during a pandemic, but the state does not have it. Voters still fill out index cards, by hand. And Maine has election day registration. In 2016, when there was talk of foreign interference and of someone taking down the network, his office worked through what would happen if the central system failed completely.
The only piece facing the internet is the central voter registration system, and it is backed up redundantly, so the voter list would probably never be lost. If it were, people would fill out the cards again and register at the polls on election day, and the elections would go on.
So we don't really have that vulnerability here in Maine, partly because we still use pens and paper, which seems to be pretty much hack-proof.
That is a politician's line, and he knows paper has its own ways to fail. Paper can be lost, copied or stuffed into a box. The more interesting part of his answer was how Maine guards against that, and it is a paper list.
Each town gets a printed list of its voters, in alphabetical order, from the central system. Maine has no electronic poll books. As ballot clerks hand a voter a ballot, they check the name off. At the end of the night the numbers have to reconcile. Say the state sends a town 1,000 ballots. Five hundred people vote in person. Three hundred request absentee ballots and 250 return them. Every one of those numbers is checked against the list, and the total always has to equal the ballots originally issued to the town. That is how you catch someone photocopying ballots or stuffing a box.
Election law is a lot like baseball, right? There's a rule for everything, but there's a reason for the rule.
It is a good line for anyone who designs systems. Maine's reconciliation is an invariant: a quantity that must be the same at the end as at the start, checked every time. Accountants call it double-entry bookkeeping. Engineers call it a checksum. And the shape of the whole system is graceful degradation. The internet-facing part is as small as it can be, and there is a paper path that can rebuild everything else. The newest component can fail without taking the election with it.
He also told me what that costs. His office is down three positions. His deputy for elections has had one day off since the Fourth of July. And with revenues falling in the pandemic, the state is asking agencies to cut their budgets. The most resilient system in the country still depends on a few people working every weekend.
There is a lesson here for anyone modernizing a public system, and it is not to avoid computers. Before you remove the paper path, make sure something else can do its job when the network is down: rebuild the record, reconcile the count, and let people keep using the service. Maine kept its paper path, and with less than three weeks to go, that looks like the right call.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 15 October 2020.
