← Back to Posts

Mid-band is where 5G pays: Peter Rysavy on the spectrum the US lacks

Sean Roberts•October 18, 2020•3 min read

I recorded three short conversations with the wireless analyst Peter Rysavy on the same morning, and I started with the broadest question: how is the United States doing on 5G compared with the rest of the world? Better than the headlines suggest, he said. Several 5G networks are running in the country with broad coverage, across several spectrum bands, and service will keep improving over the next few years.

Then I tried out something I had read, that China had opened more millimeter-wave spectrum for 5G than the United States had. He corrected me, politely.

That's slightly inaccurate. The United States actually has made a very large amount of millimeter wave spectrum available. And those are frequency bands, 24 gigahertz and higher. Those provide extremely high capacity and extremely high performance, such as gigabit per second throughputs, but they require a very dense network deployment.

Millimeter wave will matter a great deal eventually. Before that, the 5G that most people use will run in the mid-band, roughly two to six gigahertz, where in his words 5G gives the greatest bang for the buck. A mid-band network does not need as many base stations, and it still gives people hundreds of megabits a second. And that, he said, is exactly where the United States has less spectrum allocated for 5G than China.

The country does have some mid-band spectrum, but not as much as 5G needs to reach its potential, and some of what it has is not usable yet. The largest piece is the C-band, which people use to mean roughly three to four gigahertz. The FCC's auction of it begins in December, and even then it will be a year or two before carriers can build on it.

I spent part of the conversation pinning down the vocabulary, because the terms in this debate stop most people cold. Sub-6 means spectrum below six gigahertz. C-band means a slice around three to four gigahertz. Millimeter wave means twenty-four gigahertz and up. The physics underneath is simple enough to explain in a sentence. Higher frequencies carry more data but travel shorter distances and pass through walls less well, so they need many more antennas. Lower frequencies travel far but carry less. The middle is where coverage and capacity balance, which is why it is the part everyone is fighting over.

That fight is not only between countries. Inside the United States, much of the best mid-band spectrum is used by the government, the military in particular, and every megahertz moved to commercial use is negotiated. Peter's point was not that the country is losing. It is that the next stage of 5G depends on a few auctions and agreements over the next year or two, and on whether they happen on schedule.

So here is the near-term test. The C-band auction starts in December. If Peter is right, the networks that matter for most users will be built on that spectrum in 2021 and 2022, not on millimeter wave. The other two conversations from that morning went further into the hardest part, sharing spectrum with the military: how CBRS works, and the Pentagon's own idea.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 18 October 2020.

Share this post