If I can set my car on fire, I can fix it: Daniel Takash on the right to repair
My question to Daniel Takash was about the shape of the law. The DMCA's anti-circumvention rule and the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act were both written so broadly that whoever holds them can apply them almost at will. Is there any hope of cutting them back, or of replacing them with narrow laws aimed at specific harms, one for computers and another for cars?
Daniel answered from property rather than technology. Section 1201 of the DMCA penalizes anyone who breaks a digital lock to change copyrighted code, and the CFAA can turn a broken term of service into a federal matter. Combine those with products that are now mostly software, and you get an odd result.
If I own my iPhone, if I own my car, if I own, you know, I'm a hospital and I own a ventilator, it's a thumb in the eye of property rights as correctly understood to not allow people to do as they please with it. If I could set it on fire, I mean, maybe my local zoning board would get mad at me if I set my car on fire in my front lawn. But if I could set it on fire or smash it with a hammer, I should damn well be able to fix it.
The ventilator is not a hypothetical this year. Hospitals have spent 2020 keeping machines running through a pandemic, and the technicians who maintain them have been asking for the same access to repair tools and manuals that car owners want.
He called it a cruel irony that companies invoke intellectual property, in the name of defending property rights, to override the property rights of the people who bought their products. The first-sale doctrine, which lets you resell or lend a book you own without asking the publisher, exists almost everywhere else in the law. It stops at the digital lock.
Then he made an argument I had not heard put this way. He studied applied math, and his engineering friends in college were gearheads, people who love fixing and tinkering with things. Attach criminal penalties to opening up and exploring a phone, and you do more than protect a repair market. You teach a whole culture that the inside of a machine is not yours. If the country is serious about bringing manufacturing back, he said, it needs people comfortable getting their hands dirty, and a law that makes tinkering risky works against that.
The fight he pointed to was in Massachusetts. On 3 November voters approved Question 1 with about 75 percent of the vote, extending the state's 2012 car repair law to the data that new cars send wirelessly to their manufacturers. On 20 November the Alliance for Automotive Innovation sued to stop it. Daniel called the lawsuit a great example of companies blocking behavior that is acceptable under property law and consumer protection, so they can squeeze every last dollar out of the customer.
The federal exceptions are thin. The Copyright Office grants exemptions to the anti-circumvention rule, including one for repairing vehicles, but they expire every three years and have to be renewed, and the next round is under way now. A right you have to ask for again every three years is closer to a permission.
In software we take for granted that you can open what you own, read it, patch it and share the patch. Cars, phones and ventilators are computers now. I had asked whether narrow laws could replace broad ones. Daniel's answer was to start with the plainest case: an owner fixing their own machine should not need anyone's permission.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 10 December 2020.
