← Back to Posts

Break it up into what: Mark Maxham on naming the problem before the remedy

Sean Roberts•November 27, 2020•4 min read

Two weeks after we first talked, Mark Maxham came back on the show, and I gave him the question I most wanted a developer to answer. As a Facebook user, I would like to tell Twitter it may use my relationships on Facebook, through Facebook's API. That one permission would open room for startups and for new combinations of services. If we wanted to guarantee it, who would run it? Something modeled on the Open Mobility Foundation, a federal agency, something else?

Mark said he did not have a well-worked-out answer, and answered a neighboring question instead: if that is such a good idea, why isn't Facebook already doing it? Because every part of how Facebook makes money rests on exactly that data. The people running it, he said, have a duty to make as much money as possible, and nobody running Facebook knows for certain what opening the data would do to the business. When you do not know, you do not do it anyway. The big companies are nimble, he added. Apple went from computers to phones to services, and staying ahead of the market also keeps them ahead of the regulators. It is all about the bits.

Trust is the other wall. After Cambridge Analytica, Facebook will not risk that kind of public disaster again. Amazon's promise is that you click and the package arrives in two days. Apple's billboards up and down Highway 101 are about privacy now, when they are not about the camera. Anything that smells bad on trust is a flank these companies will not open.

He also pointed out a double standard he has run into himself. His company builds software for Los Angeles' mobility program, and he said plainly that this made him a little self-centered on the subject. Uber and Lyft hold enormous amounts of personal data. When Los Angeles asked mobility companies for a sliver of their trip data so it could regulate the streets, he heard a speaker at a hearing in Sacramento, from the Electronic Frontier Foundation, an organization he has given money to, compare it to ankle bracelets. In June the ACLU and the EFF sued the city over its scooter data rules. Uber, meanwhile, already operates under a Federal Trade Commission order over how it handled riders' data. There is a real privacy debate here, but it is often argued without the context of who already holds what.

Then I asked the question again, more directly. Short of a heavy-handed break-up, is there a lighter form of oversight that would give users control over their data and their relationships, and let other companies compete with them?

I think that you have to be really clear on what the problem is first, and then you can start talking about solutions. Because sometimes it feels like the only tool anybody thinks the federal government has is break up the company. I hear that and I'm like, break Facebook up into what?

Peel off WhatsApp or Instagram, he said, and you reduce what the company can offer, because the integration is worth something. Get rid of everything but the core product, and then what? Split it into the front end and the back end? Break Apple into the phone company and the music company? Apple's value is that it ties those together until the phone stops feeling like a computer and becomes an appliance that just works. He writes software for a living and tinkers with his laptop and his servers. He does not want to tinker with his phone. He wants it to work, and he wants Facebook to let him share what is going on with his friends.

Last month the House antitrust subcommittee recommended structural separations for the dominant platforms, and the Justice Department has sued Google. Before any of that becomes a remedy, Mark's test is the right one. Privacy, data portability, self-preferencing and acquisitions are different problems, and each has its own remedy. Break-up is a remedy, not a problem. Name the problem first, then ask what the remedy would actually solve.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 27 November 2020.

Share this post