A phrase that already had a meaning: Peter Rysavy on dynamic spectrum sharing
Engineers have watched good words lose their meaning before. Network, cloud and grid each meant something precise once, and then got applied to everything. Peter Rysavy, the wireless analyst, came on the show to flag the newest case, and why it matters that the government is the one doing it.
The term is dynamic spectrum sharing, abbreviated to DSS. The problem is that within 5G, there is a very specific capability called dynamic spectrum sharing. And it refers to the ability within 5G networks to be able to use the same radio channel simultaneously for 5G NR, new radio, as well as 4G LTE signals.
The base station's scheduler hands out slices of the channel, in frequency and in time, to 4G phones and 5G phones as demand shifts. That lets a carrier switch on 5G in bands where it already runs 4G, without first clearing the band of older traffic. Peter called it a fantastic innovation, and it is one reason 5G arrived in so many places so quickly.
The Department of Defense's recent request for information uses the same phrase for something entirely different: a future system in which the government shares spectrum dynamically between military and commercial users, without giving it up. The industry already had a name for that broader idea, dynamic spectrum access, or DSA. CBRS is a working, if limited, example of it. What the Pentagon has in mind is far more advanced.
Will the mix-up do damage? Not catastrophic damage, he said. It will just waste a great deal of time. Someone will argue that a new technology has to be developed, and someone else will answer that 5G already has DSS, so what is the problem, and the two will be talking about different things. He did not know why the request used the term. The Defense Innovation Board is full of clever people, and they may simply not have known about the 5G feature.
The request closed on 3 November. Peter filed comments, and the department has not published what it learned. With a new administration arriving in January, the approach may change.
Meanwhile the decision that matters more is moving. The 100 megahertz from 3.45 to 3.55 gigahertz, which the government agreed this summer to open for commercial use, is in an FCC rulemaking with an auction planned for the end of 2021. Most of the industry wants that band licensed like the C-band, the 280 megahertz going to auction next week and designed for 5G, rather than under CBRS-style sharing rules that would limit how widely it can be used. Peter did not expect the change at the FCC, where Chairman Ajit Pai has said he will step down in January, to slow any of this. There is broad bipartisan support for unencumbered 5G spectrum. Unlicensed users got a large new allocation at 6 gigahertz this year, and CBRS, which some call the innovation band, gives enterprises access they never had. The band that is short is 5G's.
Words drive budgets in government. A phrase in a request for information becomes a line in a program, then a line in a bill, and then years of work aimed at the wrong target. In code an overloaded name causes a bug. In policy it causes a wasted program. Peter's fix is simple: call the 5G feature DSS and the government's ambition DSA, and keep the two apart until the second one exists.
This was the second of our December conversations; the first was about what the networks themselves are becoming.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 2 December 2020.
