← Back to Posts

A 100-year-old rule in the counting room: Justin Roebuck on transparency

Sean Roberts•October 26, 2020•4 min read

Justin Roebuck is the clerk of Ottawa County, Michigan, and when I asked what a voter should expect from people watching an election, he drew a careful line between two roles.

A poll watcher can be anyone. Michigan law requires every precinct to have a public viewing area. From there you can see what is going on without being able to see anyone vote, but you cannot touch anything, wander around the precinct, or talk to voters. An election challenger has more rights. Challengers are appointed by a political party or another organization with an interest in the election, must be registered voters in the state, and wear a specific credential. They can see all the election materials in the precinct and stand behind the workers checking voters in, but they cannot handle anything and cannot talk to voters either. If anyone crosses into intimidation or holds up the process, the precinct's election officials can remove them.

We want the process to be open to observation, right? This is a public process. This process belongs to all of us. We're not hiding anything in the process.

The bar for a general observer is no bar at all. A Scout troop that wants to see what election day looks like, a friend who goes along with a voter, a television crew filming the precinct: all are welcome, as long as they stay in the public viewing area.

The surprise was in the room where absentee ballots are counted. In larger Michigan jurisdictions, mailed ballots are processed by absentee counting boards, separately appointed election workers, and watchers and challengers have the same rights there as in a precinct. But the counting rooms are under a sequestration law. Anyone who walks in between the opening of the polls at 7 a.m. and the close at 8 p.m. cannot leave until the polls close.

That presents an interesting challenge for transparency, honestly, because it's a little bit harder to recruit someone to observe if they know they're going to be locked in a room without use of their cell phone for a period of 14 hours.

The clerks' association would like to move to something like jury sequestration, where observers can go home at night and it is a felony to disclose what they saw. The current law, he said, does more to prevent transparency than to allow it. It has been on the books for almost a hundred years, and it made sense when it was written. Absentee ballots were counted by hand then: one worker opened a ballot and read the votes aloud while another made hash marks. Anyone in the room heard results all day.

That is not how it works anymore. Ballots move through an assembly line, and the worker who opens the envelope with a voter's name on it is not the worker who unfolds the ballot inside. A voted ballot is seen for a few seconds before it goes into a tabulator, and the tabulator produces no results until the end of the night, when the board tells it to.

Since Michigan voters approved no-reason absentee voting in 2018, these counting rooms handle far more ballots than the law's authors imagined. Security people would recognize the problem: a control designed for one threat has outlived it. The rule was meant to stop results leaking during the day, a risk the modern process already removes, and what is left of it mostly keeps observers out. When a process changes, its rules should be worked out again from the risk, not carried forward because they are old.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 26 October 2020.

Share this post