Rules that will not sit still: Aaron Tao on regulatory uncertainty
Aaron Tao works with me at Lincoln Network as a program and product manager, so this was a conversation with a colleague, and I said so on the recording. He had just published an opinion piece in the Orange County Register about AB5, California's law on who counts as an employee, and I wanted to get underneath it.
Aaron worked in California from 2013 to 2015 and then moved to Texas, citing the cost of living and his sense that the state was heading somewhere he did not want to follow. What bothered him about AB5 was less the law itself than the message it sent. For a year founders watched Uber and Lyft threaten to shut down, win a last-minute reprieve, lose in court, and finally get carved out by voters through Proposition 22 this month. Safe, as he put it, for now. His fear is that the next great founder concludes the state is not a place to start a company.
I tried to pull the conversation toward the part that is not about party or region. If I am an investor or a founder, and I think the state or the city might behave that way, uncertainty alone makes it hard to start something. If the rules at least stabilized, you could work out how to build around them.
If there's one fundamental law of social sciences, people respond to incentives. And the academic literature is very clear that a stable rule of law, simply defined as the same rules apply to everyone, it is clear, it is concise, easy to understand, it's not arbitrary, that is the foundation.
His examples were places whose legal systems grew from the common law, like Hong Kong and Singapore, where entrepreneurs could count on property rights and keep the fruits of their work. He quoted Jefferson's first inaugural address on the sum of good government: restrain people from injuring one another, and otherwise leave them free.
The idea he wanted on the record has a name. His original title for the article was about regime uncertainty, a term from the economic historian Robert Higgs, whose work Aaron helped publish when he was at the Independent Institute. Higgs used it to explain why private investment stayed on the sidelines for so long in the 1930s: when the rules keep changing, people who build for the long term wait. Economists still argue about how much it explains, but the mechanism is easy to recognize.
We ended on something we could both say without reservation. Louis Brandeis called the states laboratories of democracy, and the experiment is running. States compete for people and companies, and people move. Aaron hopes California will compete to make starting a business easier, and so do I. I have not moved to Texas.
From an engineering point of view, the useful idea here is not about California. It is that volatility is a cost of its own, separate from the burden of any single rule. An engineer can design around a constraint that holds still, however strict it is. Nobody can design around one that flips with each court ruling and ballot measure. Founders know this as risk, and investors price it as delay. It applies to every jurisdiction and every party. Before arguing about whether a rule is too strict or too loose, a lawmaker might ask whether anyone will be able to count on it for five years.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 20 November 2020.

