Parents go quiet at a dashboard: Ian Patterson on data people can use
Ian Patterson runs the studio at Lincoln Network, where I work, and for the past year he has been building Schoolahoop with a foundation partner in Tarrant County, Texas. It is a school discovery tool. A parent describes their child's interests and needs and their daily commute, and it suggests schools within reach that they had not considered: district schools, charters, low-cost private schools, hybrid programs, homeschooling, and the micro schools that parents have started calling learning pods this year. The beta covers kindergarten through fifth grade.
The research behind it found that about 80 percent of parents could name only their own school. Many believed charter schools charge tuition. Most badly overestimated what private options cost. Few had heard of micro schools. The gap was not a lack of options. Parents had no good way to discover them.
What interested me most was what Ian's team learned about the tools that already exist. Most school search sites are built, as he put it, by researchers for researchers: data-centric and wonkish. Then they watched parents use them.
Other school research solutions that are out there focus on a lot of data and a lot of metrics, ratios, and pie charts, and graphs, and percentage points down to a single percentage. And what we found in our experience of showing these to parents is that they would go to these sites, they look at them, and they would go, oh, look at all this data. And then they would get quieter and quieter and quieter.
At the end, the parents would say something like, wow, this is a lot of information, I'm really not sure what to do with it. Then they would close the browser and ask a friend, who most likely sits in the same school system with the same assumptions. So Schoolahoop was built the other way around: around what a parent already knows about their own child, the problems and the opportunities, rather than around data that may not be reliable and may not tell a parent what to do next.
I compared it to real estate. Over the past five years a whole generation of home search tools has taught people to search by what they want, not by the database the listings come from. And schools are the main reason many families move in the first place. The next steps for Schoolahoop are to cover pre-kindergarten through twelfth grade, to grow beyond Tarrant County, and to keep improving how it matches families, based on what parents are telling the team.
The sentence I wrote down was about the parents going quiet. Everyone who builds data products has seen that silence: in a demo, in a usability test, in a dashboard nobody opens a second time. It is the moment a person realizes the tool answers questions they did not ask and skips the one they did. More data does not fix it. Starting from the decision the person has to make does.
A dashboard is not a decision. People do not want the data. They want to know what to do, and why, in terms of their own situation, with the evidence one click away for when they want to check. The other half of our conversation was about public data that no one could use at all: forty states published school spending and nobody looked.
From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 9 September 2020.

