← Back to Posts

A better AdWords that no one will fund: Chris Riley on the kill zone

Sean Roberts•September 30, 2020•3 min read

I put the problem to Chris Riley as a scene. I have a great idea, and I walk into a restaurant on a street in Palo Alto where I know I will find a venture capitalist I know. My pitch is a better version of Google AdWords. The investor will not tell me the idea is bad. They will tell me there is no way to break into that market, because Google is too dominant. And they will ask how I plan to get started: am I going to build my own ad exchange network too?

Investors have a name for that territory now, the kill zone around the biggest platforms, where startups do not get funded because the incumbent can copy, buy or starve them. My question was what would change if an organization working with regulators guaranteed a fair baseline. Then my startup could design its product to work with the ad exchanges that already exist, and it would have a chance of living, breathing and getting customers.

Chris started with the founder's real constraint.

You can't start by building every single thing that you need in order to compete toe-to-toe with Google. It's not possible. So that point is the on-ramp point.

But he did not want to get ahead of the law, because none of this exists yet. In his view the first step is a legal interoperability mandate. He pointed to the final report from the United Kingdom's Competition and Markets Authority this summer, on online platforms and digital advertising, and to the ACCESS Act from Senators Warner, Hawley and Blumenthal. Getting a requirement like that into law is what he is focused on for the next twelve to eighteen months. Then you need a government agency willing to use its muscle, whatever its limits, to enforce it. Then industry comes to the table, and only then do people work out what to build.

He had an example of that sequence working. The Data Transfer Project, a voluntary effort by the big companies to move people's data between services, was inspired by the GDPR's requirement for data portability. Get the law, get a government that will enforce it, get industry to the table, and then build. After that, he said, a body like the one I described becomes a natural partner for a startup working out how to make its market entry as smooth as possible.

I said the internet is the ultimate small business: anyone can start something from scratch. He agreed, but only up to a point. The potential for growth gets cut off quickly by the number of gatekeepers a new company runs into, and unlocking that takes facilitation and, in the end, government support. The dominant players would like to hold all this off as long as possible, and the topic sits where policy, law and technology meet, which makes it slow.

What I take from the conversation is a founder's version of interoperability policy. Nobody needs to rebuild the whole stack to compete with Google. A founder needs a published, enforceable way to connect to the parts that already exist. That turns an impossible build into an integration, and it changes the question in that restaurant from whether a startup can survive to whether its idea is any good.

Earlier in the same session we talked through who would define that baseline, with messaging as the test case: who decides what a messaging baseline includes.

From Lincoln Shorts, the interview series I hosted for Lincoln Network, recorded 30 September 2020.

Share this post